Worst dilemma: unfair! Ipswich Town and Blackburn Rovers Present Their Cases to the EFL After Match Abandonment as EFL officially planing to favour one team_leaving the other team in serious huddles…See full details..
In the wake of the controversial ending to the Championship fixture between Blackburn Rovers and Ipswich Town at Ewood Park, both clubs have formally submitted their arguments to the English Football League (EFL) over what they believe should happen next. The game was abandoned in the 80th minute due to a waterlogged pitch — just ten minutes shy of full time.
—
What Happened
The match was called off by referee Stephen Martin after sustained heavy rainfall made the pitch unplayable. At the time of abandonment, Blackburn were leading 1-0 thanks to a penalty by Todd Cantwell.
Ipswich were down to ten men after centre-back Jacob Greaves received a red card in the 49th minute.
—
What Both Clubs Want
Both Blackburn and Ipswich now want the EFL to agree with their respective interpretations of fairness under the rules. They have put forward separate cases on how the result should be handled.
Blackburn Rovers’ Position:
Rovers’ case is understood to argue either that the result should stand – awarding them the win – since the vast majority of the match had been played, or alternatively, that only the remaining minutes should be replayed.
They claim that to reverse or replay the entire fixture is unfair in light of their lead, the limited time left, and the resources invested, especially given the circumstances within the match up to that point.
Ipswich Town’s Case:
Ipswich are pushing for a full replay of the match. They believe that even though 80 minutes were played, the abandonment — caused by factors outside their control — undermines the fairness of concluding the fixture with the current score.
The red card for Greaves will stand under disciplinary rules regardless of the outcome of the match result.
—
The Rules and Precedents
Under EFL regulations, if a match is abandoned for reasons beyond the control of either club, the Board can order the match to be replayed in full or in part, or even allow the result to stand, depending on the circumstances.
FA Rule 20(E)(iii) also comes into play: it states that when a competition match is abandoned for no fault of the clubs, it should be replayed in its entirety on a date agreed by both clubs and approved by the competition.
Historical precedent suggests the EFL may favour a full replay in these kinds of circumstances, especially when fewer than the full 90 minutes have been completed and when environmental issues (rain/pitch state) are the root cause.
—
What Happens Next
The EFL Board will review the submitted cases from both clubs and make a decision. It is likely that the Board will take into account how much of the match was completed, the cause of abandonment, fairness, match conditions, safety, and any precedents.
There is some speculation among observers and media that a full replay is the most probable outcome.
If a replay is ordered, the clubs will need to agree on a date; the EFL will facilitate this. If the match result is allowed to stand, Blackburn would receive the three points. If only the remaining time is replayed, logistical issues such as player availability, substitutions, continuity of disciplinary sanctions and possibly cost implications will have to be worked out.
—
Broader Reactions
Fans on both sides have reacted strongly. Blackburn supporters feel aggrieved at the possibility of losing out despite being in the lead, while Ipswich fans argue that the abandonment was unavoidable and that restarting cleanly is the fairest route.
Commentary also has focused on pitch drainage and ground maintenance at Ewood Park, with some observers suggesting that the conditions were borderline unplayable well before the match was abandoned.
—
Implications
Whichever decision the EFL makes could have a bearing on both clubs’ positions in the Championship table. Three points for Blackburn might lift them up in the standings; a replay gives Ipswich a chance to avoid defeat in a fair contest.
The case also sets a precedent for how future abandoned matches under similar conditions might be handled, especially with increasing concerns about weather extremes and stadium pitch quality.
Likely Outcome
While nothing is confirmed yet, judging by the rules and recent reports:
The most likely outcome is a full replay of the match.
It is less likely the EFL will simply award Blackburn the win, given that rules typically avoid rewarding a side where the match has not been played in full, especially under forced abandonment.
A partial replay (only the remaining 10 minutes) is possible but poses more logistical challenges and is considered less probable.
Both clubs now wait for an official ruling from the EFL Board. Fans on both sides will be watching closely, as the decision will not only resolve this particular fixture but may influence how similar situations are resolved in the future.
Leave a Reply